Choose a reason to join that survives launch week
“Meet other business owners” is broad. “A working group for small-business founders testing one customer-growth experiment each month” explains both the people and the activity. Choose a problem that benefits from repeated interaction, not just a downloadable answer.
Ask potential members how they handle that problem today, where they get stuck, and what they could contribute. Listen for a shared need and differences that could make introductions valuable. A group of people with identical questions and no experience to share may need more facilitation than you expect.
Community Finder is the starting resource I have built for this decision. It helps turn an idea into a format and first activity. The stages below are a working plan for building from scratch in public, not a report that I have already recruited 100 members or achieved particular results.
Members 1–10: Recruit a founding group personally
Start with people whose needs fit the promise: existing professional relationships, readers who have asked about the problem, or people already participating in a relevant conversation. Ask individually rather than adding an entire contact list. Be specific about why the invitation fits them.
Explain what is ready, what is still experimental, and what you need from participants. State whether the pilot is free or paid, its duration, and what happens afterward. Invite feedback as well as attendance. Ten people who understand the experiment are more useful than a large list that cannot explain why it joined.
Give each new member a useful first connection
A welcome should help a person do something immediately. Ask what they are working on, what help they need, and what they can offer. Keep requests proportionate: members should not have to publish revenue figures, client names, or confidential plans to participate.
Make introductions with permission and a reason. “You both run businesses” is weak. “You are testing a referral offer, and Morgan has offered to review one invitation draft” gives the connection a purpose. Make it easy for either person to decline.
- Send a short welcome with one action and the date of the next activity.
- Ask for one current challenge and one area where the member can help.
- Suggest a relevant peer connection and check that both people want it.
- Follow up after the first activity to learn what helped and where they got stuck.
Members 10–30: Make one activity repeatable
Choose a rhythm that produces value without requiring the founder to supply every answer. For example, members share a customer-growth experiment on Monday, exchange feedback midweek, and report what they learned on Friday. Adjust the schedule to the actual time people can give.
Keep the experience small enough to facilitate well. On Mighty, start with a clear welcome, a place for the core activity, and the next gathering. Use current product guidance for account setup. Adding more spaces before members have a habit can make the next action harder to find.
Review unanswered requests and introductions that went nowhere. Ask members who did not return what prevented participation. Sometimes the promise is right but the format is too demanding. Simplify before recruiting the next group.
Members 30–60: Invite through evidence of value
Once the first experience is repeatable, ask members whether they know someone facing the same problem. Offer a clear invitation they can forward, without pressuring them to share contacts. You can also host a sample session with a complementary professional group whose audience fits the promise.
Show the activity in public using your own materials or examples shared with explicit permission. A sample feedback exercise tells a prospective member more than a claim that the community is amazing. Keep private conversations and member results private unless you have permission to publish them.
Distinguish interest from membership. In a planning example, 40 invitations might lead to 20 replies and 8 joins. That is arithmetic for understanding the funnel, not an expected conversion rate. Record the actual numbers and reasons for declining before deciding how much outreach is needed.
Members 60–100: Share the hosting work carefully
More members create more opportunities for connection and more chances for requests to go unanswered. Invite willing members to host a narrow activity, welcome a small group, or share a specific skill. Agree on the responsibility, time commitment, and support rather than assuming enthusiastic members want unpaid jobs.
Write clear participation expectations and identify who handles concerns. Keep the core experience easy to find as the group grows. If members need different activities, test a small subgroup before redesigning the whole community.
Pause recruitment if the welcome or core activity is falling behind. Reaching 100 registered accounts while members struggle to find value is a weaker foundation than a smaller group with a repeatable reason to return.
Publish the experiment, including what did not work
Building in public is most credible when updates describe decisions and observations. Share the promise you are testing, the invitation, what people actually did, and one change for the next round. Separate a hypothesis from a result. A useful update can explain that a session format was too long and show the shorter version.
Use aggregate counts and permission-based examples. There is no need to expose private member discussions to demonstrate progress. Avoid turning every update into another recruitment announcement; teach readers something they can apply to their own group.
Measure participation and business value separately
Track joins, completion of the first meaningful action, return participation, peer responses, and host time. For a cohort of 20 new members, 12 completing the first activity means 60% activation under that definition. Review return participation for that same cohort over a stated period rather than mixing old and new members.
Define the business outcome separately: paid membership, better customer adoption, or qualified service conversations. Revenue, costs, and retention matter for a paid community; registered accounts alone do not establish a sustainable people business.
There is no universal deadline for reaching 100. Grow at the pace your audience, offer, and hosting capacity support. The milestone matters when members can describe why they belong and find value beyond access to the founder.
Product references
This is a suggested working plan, not an official setup manual. For current features, trial terms, and account instructions, see Mighty’s pricing and plan details and the Mighty Help Center. Product features and terms may change; check these sources before choosing a plan.
Building from scratch? Read the complete guide to starting an online community.
