Back to NilsSmith.com

Community building

How to start an online community.

Start with a specific group of people and one reason for them to return. Choose a format you can sustain, plan a useful first activity, and invite a small founding group before expanding.

From Nils Smith · VP of Marketing at Mighty

1. Give people a reason to gather

An audience listens to you. A community gives people reasons to interact with each other. Before choosing features or a name, describe who belongs and what they will do together.

Use this starting sentence: “This community helps [specific people] achieve [a useful outcome] through [something we do together].”

For example, “This community helps first-time managers practice difficult conversations through weekly role-play and peer feedback.” That promise suggests both the people to invite and the first activity to host.

2. Choose a community format you can sustain

These five formats are the starting points used by Community Finder. Choose the one that best describes why members would return. You can combine activities later.

Learning community

Members develop a skill or deepen their knowledge together. Learning partners exchange feedback, share examples, and help each other apply what they learn.

A starting format: A guided learning cohort.

Watch for: Too much teaching can leave little room for connection. Keep the lesson short and give members time to practice and respond to one another.

Accountability community

Members follow through on a specific goal. Members make commitments visible, encourage one another, and learn from what helps others follow through.

A starting format: A four-week challenge with weekly check-ins.

Watch for: Missed goals can make people disappear. Normalize adjusting commitments and welcome honest check-ins, including when progress is slow.

Peer network

Members find trusted people who understand their work or situation. Peers offer perspective, introductions, and advice grounded in experience that no single person can supply alone.

A starting format: Curated introductions and small-group conversations.

Watch for: A large list of names is not a network. Start with a few relevant introductions, clear expectations, and a conversation people can contribute to.

Interest community

Members connect around a shared passion, identity, or life stage. Members bring their own stories, discoveries, and perspectives, creating belonging through participation rather than passive consumption.

A starting format: Recurring conversations and member gatherings.

Watch for: Broad topics can make participation feel vague. Choose a specific prompt and personally welcome each new voice.

Mission community

Members work together toward a shared cause. Members combine skills, share responsibility, and take coordinated action that would be harder to sustain alone.

A starting format: A focused initiative with clear participation opportunities.

Watch for: A big mission can overwhelm willing people. Name one achievable outcome and offer small, clearly bounded ways to help.

Not sure which fits? Take the free Community Finder assessment for a recommendation tailored to your goals and available time.

3. Make the first month manageable

You do not need a full content library to learn whether people want to participate. Start with one repeatable activity and a schedule you can actually keep.

  1. Week 1: Welcome and listen. Invite a small group personally. Ask each person what they hope to gain and introduce members with shared interests.
  2. Week 2: Do one useful thing together. Run a practice session, a check-in, or a focused discussion that delivers on your member promise.
  3. Week 3: Help members respond to each other. Invite people to share progress, offer feedback, or bring a question to the group.
  4. Week 4: Ask what is worth repeating. Review participation and member feedback. Keep what helped, simplify what did not, and set the next date.

If you do not have an audience yet, begin with conversations. Ask a few potential members what they are trying to accomplish and whether they would join a small pilot around that goal.

4. Give your community a home on Mighty

Once your purpose is clear, use your plan to set up a first version on Mighty: introduce the member promise, create a place for the first activity, and write a welcome prompt that makes it easy to participate.

Your assessment result includes setup suggestions for your format. You will create your Mighty account separately and copy the relevant parts of your plan yourself; the assessment does not transfer your answers or build the community automatically.

I’m VP of Marketing at Mighty. The Community Finder assessment is free whether or not you choose Mighty. Check Mighty’s website for its current trial terms and pricing.

Explore your next question

Go deeper with practical articles on finding your first members, planning a weekly rhythm, and your first two weeks on Mighty. Or browse the article library.