Write the problem without naming the technology

“We need an AI agent” starts with a proposed purchase. “Members wait two days to find the right onboarding resource” identifies an experience to improve. The second statement leaves room for several solutions, including clearer navigation or a better welcome message.

Ask who experiences the problem, how often it occurs, and what happens when it remains unresolved. A visually impressive demo may solve a problem your customers do not have. The goal of evaluation is to distinguish a useful capability from a compelling presentation.

This approach applies to emerging tools such as AI assistants, immersive event experiences, and new automation systems. Each needs its own technical review. A common decision process helps leaders ask consistent questions without pretending those technologies have identical risks.

Use five questions before comparing vendors

A scorecard should expose assumptions, not turn guesses into scientific-looking numbers. For each dimension, write the evidence you have, the evidence missing, and the person responsible for checking it. Mark an unanswered question as unknown rather than awarding an optimistic score.

  1. Customer value: What task becomes easier, and how will a user notice?
  2. Workflow fit: What existing process changes, and who owns the handoff?
  3. Trust and risk: What data is used, who can access it, and what happens when the tool is wrong?
  4. Total cost: What will setup, integration, training, review, support, and exit require?
  5. Reversibility: Can you export essential records and continue serving people if you stop?

Design a pilot that can fail usefully

Choose a small, appropriate group and tell participants what is being tested. Set the duration and success criteria before seeing results. For a resource-finding assistant, a useful comparison might include correct answers, unresolved questions, time to help, and member satisfaction with the experience.

Include realistic difficult cases rather than only examples selected by the vendor. Check missing information, ambiguous questions, and requests the tool should pass to a person. A system that answers every question confidently may perform worse than one that recognizes its limits.

Count the work around the subscription

A monthly price is only one part of cost. Teams may need to prepare content, configure permissions, connect systems, train colleagues, and handle errors. Include time spent maintaining the source material after launch. An assistant built on outdated instructions still needs someone to correct the instructions.

Ask how costs change with usage and what happens if a key integration fails. Request a demonstration of export and deletion rather than assuming the options exist. If the proposal depends on a feature promised for later, evaluate the current product separately from the roadmap.

Apply the same discipline to your people business

For a community business on Mighty, start with the member experience you want to improve: a clearer welcome, a better event, or faster access to help. Test what your existing setup can do before adding another tool and another login. Confirm current capabilities and account requirements in the product’s documentation.

A new feature should earn its place by making participation easier or delivery more sustainable. If it adds complexity that members must learn without a clear benefit, postpone it. Novelty can support an experience, but it should not become the reason the experience is difficult to use.

End the review with a decision: adopt with an owner, run a narrower test, wait for a missing capability, or decline. Document why and set a review trigger if needed. This gives the team permission to learn without making every experiment a permanent commitment.

Building from scratch? Read the complete guide to starting an online community.