Compare the promise, not just the payment model
A course organizes learning around a destination. A membership organizes an ongoing experience around a continuing need. A cohort gives a group a shared start and finish. These formats can overlap: a membership can include courses, and a course can include peer discussion. The useful question is what participants need next, not which label sounds more scalable.
For an illustrative example, an operations consultant might teach new managers how to create their first team planning system in a four-week course. Once they have a working system, a smaller group may want ongoing conversations about difficult management situations. That second need could support a membership, but it should be tested separately rather than assumed.
A recurring payment does not create recurring value. Equally, a useful course does not need endless new lessons. Write down what someone should be able to do at the end of the learning experience and why they might still want other people afterward.
Use four questions to choose your starting format
Ask these questions in conversations with potential participants. Listen for examples of situations they have actually faced. A general expression of enthusiasm is less useful than a description of the last time they tried to solve the problem.
- Is there a clear finish line? A defined skill or completed project points toward a course or cohort.
- Does the problem recur? New decisions, changing circumstances, or continued practice may support a membership.
- Do participants need one another? Feedback, introductions, and accountability give a community a job beyond distributing content.
- What can you deliver consistently? Compare your preparation, facilitation, support, and administration time before promising an ongoing experience.
Test the experience before recording a large course
Start with a small group and one observable outcome. Choose a planning size you can support personally, such as six to ten participants; this is a suggested experiment, not an industry benchmark. Explain the dates, activities, expected effort, price if any, and what happens when the pilot ends.
Prepare only the first activity and an outline of what follows. You still owe participants a coherent experience, but you can refine examples around the questions they bring. If the pilot is about producing a usable client brief, have each participant bring a real or fictional draft and exchange specific feedback.
Record where people need instruction, where they need practice, and where they need a conversation. Those observations help you decide which elements belong in lessons and which should remain facilitated. Get explicit permission before recording participants or reusing their contributions.
Budget for the work between sessions
A membership can look simple on a calendar while requiring considerable work between gatherings. Welcoming newcomers, answering questions, making introductions, and resolving confusion all consume time. A course also needs maintenance, learner support, and clear expectations about access.
Estimate a typical month before choosing a price or committing to a schedule. For example, two hours of preparation, two hours of live delivery, and four hours of support add up to eight hours of work before promotion and administration. These are illustrative numbers. Replace them with your actual capacity and include the less visible tasks.
Avoid promising unlimited personal access unless you have a clear way to deliver it. State where questions belong, when someone can expect a response, and what is outside the offer. A smaller promise that you can consistently fulfill is a better foundation for trust.
Choose a platform after defining the experience
List the essential requirements: lesson access, member discussion, events, payments if needed, and a straightforward welcome. Test these from a participant’s perspective. Someone should understand the first action without a guided tour of your entire setup.
Mighty supports communities, courses, events, and memberships. Check the current pricing page for which capabilities are included in the plan you are evaluating. For a pilot, build only the welcome and the first shared activity; you do not need to fill every available space.
If your course already lives elsewhere, do not move it simply to start this experiment. First identify what participants cannot do today and whether a new community experience would address that gap.
Let participant behavior inform the next offer
Review whether people reached the intended outcome, helped each other, and asked for a specific next experience. Distinguish “I enjoyed this” from “I want ongoing help with this recurring problem.” Both are useful feedback, but they support different decisions.
Continue as a course if the defined learning path is the value. Test a membership if people describe a continuing need and choose to return for it. If neither is clear, revise the promise before investing in more content. You do not need to launch every possible format at once.
Sources and further reading
Product references
This is a suggested working plan, not an official setup manual. For current features, trial terms, and account instructions, see Mighty’s pricing and plan details and the Mighty Help Center. Product features and terms may change; check these sources before choosing a plan.
Building from scratch? Read the complete guide to starting an online community.
